New York Hire Now

Job Information

Plymouth Rock Assurance Claims Representative, Casualty in Uniondale, New York

Plymouth Rock has been awarded the #1 Large Employer in New Jersey in 2021. We would love for you to join our award winning team!

The Casualty Claim Representative will be responsible for the handling of First and Third Party Bodily Injury and Physical Damage claims in a Personal Lines /Commercial environment for the Plymouth Rock Operation. The candidate must have the skills listed below and be able to perform the following duties:

Essential Functions and Responsibilities

  • Initiate prompt contact of all insureds/claimants/witnesses on all new claim assignments to conduct thorough coverage and liability/injury investigations. These investigations might require the representatives take in depth recorded statements to investigate coverage and liability/injury claims.

  • Analyze, review and interpret policies to assess coverage and liability. Provide advice to Excess and Primary coverage issues.

  • Willing to conduct field investigations, interviews with insureds, witnesses and claimants while maintaining a pending of represented claimant cases.

  • Manage and direct outside vendors (Field/Counsel/Surveillance, Etc..) to determine what investigation is necessary and give them direction to bring a claim to conclusion. Ensure only necessary work is completed.

  • Investigate cases timely so that reserves are established and maintained at proper levels. Revise reserves timely based on developments in the course of the claim.

  • Investigate the validity of bodily injury claims being presented by individual insureds/claimants or attorneys representing insureds/claimants. Be aware of certain “Red Flags” to identify potential fraudulent claims. Refer to SIU for investigation timely.

  • Have advanced skills in coverage, investigation, litigation/ legal issues, negotiations, evaluations, medical terminology, and subrogation. Handle more complex claims to include coverage issues, UM/UIM, etc.. Also, must have prior litigation handling.

  • Recognize and investigate subrogation potential.

  • Negotiate both 1st and 3rd party claims directly with injured parties or their attorneys.

  • Exercises proper judgment and decision making to analyze exposure, determine the proper course of action and make recommendations for final resolution.

  • Attend litigation proceedings to either represent the company or participate in arbitrations/depositions/settlement conferences/ mediations/ trials.

  • Attend all internal and external training events as required.

  • Participate in proactive team activities to achieve departmental and company objectives. May be asked to participate in special projects, committees or assignments from management.

  • Possess strong organizational skills, able to demonstrate time management, has the ability to prioritize multiple tasks/duties, and be proficient in the utilization of all claims systems, Excel, Word and social media search engines.

  • Have strong communication skills both verbal and written. Provide strong customer service. Prepare case summary for significant reserve increase and/or trial alerts. Participate in roundtables.

  • Capable of working independently without close supervision, high level of self-motivation, effectively manage workload while maintaining diary and focus on claims quality.

  • Ability to handle multiple responsibilities and be adept at conflict resolution while working in a team environment. Work well under pressure. Able to think strategically, solve problems, set priorities, make the necessary decisions to resolve complex/regular issues/claims.

  • Possess knowledge of and adherence to State(s) laws and regulatory claim handling guidelines and statutory regulations.

  • Adhere to departmental internal control requirements. Comply with Plymouth Rock’s standards, best practices and ethical guidelines, adhere to Plymouth Rock’s culture.

Qualifications and Education

  • A bachelor's degree (B.A.) from an accredited four year college or university.

  • 3 - 5 years’ experience handling liability and/or Personal Injury Protection claims.

  • Some litigation experience and knowledge of the New Jersey court system is preferred.

  • Knowledge of PA, CT or NY claims handling would be beneficial.

  • Currently holds and/or can readily obtain an out of State License(s) (i.e. - CT, Delaware, Florida, etc.) is preferred.

About the Company

The Plymouth Rock Company and its affiliated group of companies write and manage over $1.6 billion in personal and commercial auto and homeowner’s insurance throughout the Northeast and mid-Atlantic, where we have built an unparalleled reputation for service. We continuously invest in technology, our employees thrive in our empowering environment, and our customers are among the most loyal in the industry. The Plymouth Rock group of companies employs more than 1,900 people and is headquartered in Boston, Massachusetts. Plymouth Rock Assurance Corporation holds an A.M. Best rating of “A-/Excellent”.


Job ID: 2023-3722

External Company URL:

Street: 50 Charles Lindbergh Boulevard Suite 401